A satisfying combat loop gets people to try a roguelike once. What keeps them is the economy around it - the choices that make run two different from run one.
Decisions are the replay value
In Streetvers the buff-card draft between waves is where the game actually lives: 33 buff types means every run forks early and often. The territory base layer and sigil tree stack meta-decisions on top of the moment-to-moment.
Players forgive a simple loop with rich decisions. They abandon a rich loop with no decisions.
Use a substrate so the budget goes to design
- Build on a proven combat engine so you're not re-inventing input.
- Spend the saved time on the economy, the meta-progression, and game feel.
- Tune the systems that create variety, not just the ones that create motion.